So, you’ve just spent the morning pulling apart one of your most expensive possessions and when you’ve finished putting it all back togrther, it doen’t work.
I’d attempted to replace an aluminum G4 Powerbooks’ hard drive, but the new disk wasn’t visible.
When attempting to reinstall Mac OS, the installer can’t see the new disk. It turns out that the disk was working, but wouldn’t show as an install target until it was partitioned. The Disk Utility under Utilities in the menu bar can be used to partition and format the new disk.
Problem solved. Blood pressure returning to normal.
However, two things;
- Isn’t it abit strange to have a menubar on a fullscreen install program; I won’t have thought to look for one.
- Shouldn’t the install target dialog box drop a hint about the shiny new unformatted drive?
The other interesting thing is how long had this disk been in an unbootable state?
It did start making worrying comments in the syslog towards the end of last summer. Powerbooks tend to have uptimes in the months because you just shut the lid when you’re not using it; they hardly ever get booted from cold. Also considering that you probably never touch large portions of the disk from day to day, this could well have been broken for months.
The other slightly worrying thing is that on boot, Mac OS seems to run a fsck -A on the damaged disk.
This is probably why it managed to keep going for as long as it did, but surely performing unprompted write operations on a potentially damaged disk is risking making the situation even worse?
The OS also seems todo this without prompting when you try to attach the extracted disk as a USB device.
If the fcsk fails, you won’t be given the mount. Killing the fsck process did however cause the mount point to come up on one occasion, which was enough time to recover the required files.